Exceptional front-desk service is the most powerful driver of hotel reputation and revenue in Romania. Learn city-specific tactics, scripts, KPIs, salary benchmarks, and SOPs that turn check-in moments into lasting loyalty.
Beyond Check-In: The Impact of Stellar Customer Service on Hotel Reputation in Romania
Romania's hospitality scene is changing fast. International brands are opening new properties, independent hotels are elevating their design and amenities, and guests are comparing options with a thumb swipe. In this landscape, the front desk is more than a point of transaction. It is the make-or-break moment for reputation, revenue, and long-term guest loyalty. One outstanding interaction can turn a first-time visitor into a lifelong advocate. One unresolved complaint can live on in reviews for years.
This post explores how exceptional customer service - especially at reception - shapes a hotel's public image and commercial performance in Romania. We will connect the dots between guest interactions and online reputation, show city-specific expectations in Bucharest, Cluj-Napoca, Timisoara, and Iasi, and share practical playbooks: service scripts, KPIs, hiring guidance, training plans, and daily checklists. Whether you run a 5-star business hotel in Bucharest or a boutique property in Cluj-Napoca, these strategies will help your team deliver service that guests remember and reviews celebrate.
Receptionists Are Romania's Most Influential Marketers
Your marketing budget can buy ads and billboards. But the most persuasive reputation asset is a real guest telling a real story. In Romania, as everywhere, those stories start at reception.
- First and last impressions: Arrival is the first emotional contact and checkout is the final taste left in the guest's memory. A warm welcome and a graceful goodbye anchor the overall experience.
- Moment-to-moment influence: Receptionists shape outcomes when flights are delayed at OTP, when a credit card fails, when a guest needs an urgent invoice for a government meeting in Bucharest, or when a family arrives early from Cluj-Napoca and hopes for a room at 9:30 a.m.
- Trust in uncertainty: Travelers choose hotels based on perceived risk. Guests relax when they sense the front desk can solve problems. That trust itself becomes value - higher tolerance for hiccups, better reviews, and more direct bookings.
If you think of reception as a marketing channel, every shift becomes an opportunity to increase review scores, repeat rates, and upsells. It is not about charm alone. It is about systematized empathy and consistent execution.
How Service Drives Reputation, Occupancy, and Rate
Great service does more than feel good. It produces measurable results in Romania's distribution ecosystem.
- Better OTA visibility and conversion
- Booking platforms like Booking.com, Expedia, and Hotels.com promote properties with higher review scores and robust response rates. An improvement from 8.6 to 9.0 on Booking.com can move a hotel several result pages up and increase conversion significantly.
- Google Reviews and Google Hotel Ads weigh rating averages and recency. A consistent 4.5+ star profile with fresh responses attracts more click-throughs from domestic and international travelers.
- TripAdvisor rankings factor in quality, quantity, and recency. Engaged management responses signal accountability to potential guests.
- Stronger corporate and group demand
- Procurement teams for multinational companies in Bucharest and Cluj-Napoca review online feedback and request references during RFP seasons. A reputation for reliable service at reception reduces perceived risk and tips awards in your favor.
- MICE planners in Timisoara and Iasi assess front-office competence for check-in logistics, VIP handling, and invoice accuracy. Poor accounts handling at checkout can disqualify a hotel from future events.
- Better pricing power
- Guests will pay more for certainty. If your review profile consistently celebrates problem-solving, cleanliness communication, and billing accuracy, you can maintain a premium ADR even in shoulder seasons.
- Lower cost to serve
- Clear communication at check-in reduces mid-stay questions. Accurate preferences reduce follow-up calls. Proactive service reduces compensation costs after incidents.
In short: service quality at reception is upstream of revenue. Treat it as a profit center, not a cost center.
Local Context: What Guests Expect in Bucharest, Cluj-Napoca, Timisoara, and Iasi
While core hospitality behaviors are universal, expectations vary by city, travel purpose, and season. Tailoring front-office tactics to local demand produces better outcomes.
Bucharest: Fast, business-friendly, invoice-accurate
- Guest mix: Corporate travelers, government delegations, conference attendees, and weekend leisure guests exploring the Old Town.
- Service priorities:
- Fast check-in with clear deposit and payment policies.
- Invoice-ready checkout with company details and VAT compliance.
- Strong English plus an additional language is a competitive edge (often Italian, French, or Spanish).
- Early breakfast or Grab-and-Go for morning flights from OTP.
- Common friction points: Parking explanations, incidental hold amounts, late-night noise near Old Town weekends, and room readiness before noon for early arrivals.
Cluj-Napoca: Tech-savvy, lifestyle-driven, loyalty-minded
- Guest mix: IT and startup visitors, academic conferences, medical tourists, and football or music event attendees.
- Service priorities:
- Digital convenience: pre-arrival messaging, mobile keys where available, reliable Wi-Fi onboarding.
- Local curation: third wave coffee, casual fine dining, running routes, and co-working tips.
- Friendly but efficient tone; guests expect the team to be solution-oriented and knowledgeable.
- Common friction points: Peak event periods with citywide compression, ride-hailing pickup points, and room noise near nightlife streets.
Timisoara: Industrial hubs and cultural travelers
- Guest mix: Automotive and manufacturing business travelers, cross-border visitors from Serbia and Hungary, and culture lovers.
- Service priorities:
- Multi-language capability including some Hungarian or Serbian greetings is appreciated.
- Clear driving directions, parking, and early departures to TSR airport.
- Group and crew check-ins done with precision.
- Common friction points: Room temperature questions in shoulder seasons, weekend check-ins for sports tournaments, and invoice split requests.
Iasi: Academic, medical, and heritage stays
- Guest mix: University visitors, medical tourists, regional business, and domestic leisure exploring Moldavia's heritage sites.
- Service priorities:
- Gentle, patient communication; many guests appreciate extra guidance about transport and clinics.
- Family-friendly touches and quiet-room requests.
- Flexible checkout when treatment schedules shift.
- Common friction points: Accessibility expectations, taxi arrangements, and clear explanations of tourist information.
The SALUT Framework: A Romanian-Ready Service Blueprint
Turn good intentions into reliable habits using this practical five-step framework tailored for front desks in Romania. SALUT keeps interactions simple, human, and effective.
-
S - Smile and signal welcome
- Make eye contact within 3 seconds.
- Stand up or lean forward slightly to show attention.
- Use a warm greeting and the guest name if known.
- Example phrases:
- English: Good afternoon and welcome. How may I assist you today?
- Romanian: Buna ziua, bine ati venit. Cu ce va pot ajuta?
-
A - Acknowledge and clarify the request
- Paraphrase the request to confirm understanding.
- Ask one or two focused questions.
- Example: I understand you need an early check-in around 10 a.m., correct?
-
L - Listen actively and show empathy
- Use short verbal nods: Of course, I see, Absolutely.
- Match the guest's emotional tone without mirroring frustration.
- Example: I can imagine it has been a long journey. Let me see what we can do right now.
-
U - Unlock options and explain next steps
- Offer at least two options when possible.
- Be transparent about timing, costs, and policies.
- Example: I can prioritize housekeeping and aim for a room by 11:30, or I can store your luggage now and offer coffee in the lobby.
-
T - Take action and follow through
- Do what you promised and update within the time frame.
- Document the request in the PMS so colleagues can continue seamlessly.
- Close the loop with a brief confirmation and a smile.
SALUT is not a script. It is a sequence. Apply it consistently, and you will reduce complaints while increasing compliments.
Moments of Truth at the Front Desk: 12 Scenarios and Winning Responses
Use these scenarios to coach your team. Each example shows language and process that build trust.
- Early arrival after a night train to Bucharest
- Winning response: Acknowledge fatigue, check inventory for a clean room, and offer a comfort option.
- Script: Thank you for arriving early. I will check if a clean room is available now. If not, I will prioritize housekeeping and aim for 11:30. Meanwhile, let me store your luggage and offer you a coffee and Wi-Fi access.
- Credit card declines at check-in
- Winning response: Protect dignity, explain neutrally, and propose alternatives.
- Script: It looks like this card did not go through for the preauthorization. Sometimes banks block international transactions. Would you like to try again, use a different card, or make a small cash deposit?
- Noise complaint from a guest in Cluj-Napoca near nightlife
- Winning response: Immediate empathy plus action, then a follow-up.
- Script: I am sorry for the disturbance. I will call security to address the noise now. I can also move you to a courtyard room. May I offer earplugs for tonight and a light late checkout tomorrow?
- Overbooking on a busy Timisoara weekend
- Winning response: Own the problem, secure an equivalent or better room elsewhere, and cover transport.
- Script: We accept full responsibility for this situation. I have secured a room at our partner hotel 5 minutes away at no extra cost. We will cover the taxi and include breakfast. If you agree, we will transfer you now and remain available for assistance.
- Room readiness delay in Iasi for a medical guest
- Winning response: Prioritize compassion and speed, with a quiet space.
- Script: We want you to rest as soon as possible. I have prioritized your room with housekeeping. It will be ready by 12:00. Meanwhile, we have a quiet lounge where you can relax. Can I prepare tea or water for you?
- Invoice split for a Bucharest corporate stay
- Winning response: Demonstrate competence.
- Script: Certainly. I will issue one invoice for room and breakfast to the company and a second invoice for minibar and extras in your name. May I confirm the company tax ID and address?
- OTA booking mismatch
- Winning response: Show good faith and be transparent.
- Script: I see the confusion with the breakfast inclusion. While I verify the listing, I will honor breakfast for tonight. Thank you for showing me your confirmation.
- Lost item after checkout in Cluj-Napoca
- Winning response: Log, search, and update within a clear time frame.
- Script: I have created a lost item report with your phone and email. Housekeeping will check the room and laundry today. I will update you by 6 p.m., even if there is no news yet.
- Accessibility need in Iasi
- Winning response: Clarify needs and present real options.
- Script: Thank you for letting us know. Do you prefer a room with a roll-in shower or grab bars by the bath? I will assign a room near the elevator and arrange a shower chair now.
- Flight delay out of OTP and late checkout
- Winning response: Balance occupancy limits with flexible solutions.
- Script: I can extend checkout to 2 p.m. as a courtesy. If you need more time, we can store your luggage and offer our lounge. I can also book a shower room at 5 p.m. for a quick refresh before your airport transfer.
- Birthday moment in Timisoara
- Winning response: Personalize.
- Script: Happy birthday from all of us. We have prepared a small surprise in your room and a note from our team. May we also add a late checkout tomorrow?
- Card preauth communication at check-in
- Winning response: Prevent negative surprises.
- Script: To keep your folio open for incidental charges, we place a temporary hold of 300 RON on your card. This is not a payment and will be released by your bank after checkout.
Measuring What Matters: Front-Office KPIs and Dashboards
What gets measured gets improved. Track a focused set of service and revenue indicators that your reception team can influence directly.
Service quality KPIs
- CSAT post-stay survey: target 90 percent plus satisfied or very satisfied.
- NPS: aim for 50 or higher for business hotels, 60 plus for boutique or resort properties.
- OTA review average: Booking.com 9.0 plus, Google 4.5 plus, TripAdvisor 4.5 plus.
- Response time to online reviews: 100 percent of reviews answered within 72 hours; 24 hours for 3-star and below ratings.
- Complaints per 100 stays: track by category - cleanliness communication, noise, billing, maintenance.
Revenue and efficiency KPIs
- Upsell revenue per occupied room: target 2 to 6 EUR per occupied room from upgrades, breakfast add-ons, parking, or late checkout.
- Prearrival upsell conversion: 7 to 15 percent on targeted offers.
- Average check-in time: under 4 minutes for FIT, under 15 minutes for groups per bus.
- First-contact resolution: 80 percent of issues solved without escalation.
- Training hours per receptionist per quarter: 8 to 12 hours.
Weekly dashboard cadence
- Monday: review weekend reviews and social mentions; select 3 positive examples and 1 improvement tactic.
- Wednesday: midweek upsell performance review; adjust offer mix and price points.
- Friday: celebrate fast check-in stats and shout-out top service recovery moments.
Tech That Empowers Receptionists - Not Replaces Them
Technology should remove friction so humans can be more human. Choose tools that integrate cleanly and save clicks.
Core stack to consider in Romania
- PMS: Oracle Opera, Protel, Mews, Cloudbeds - choose based on property size and integration needs.
- Channel manager: SiteMinder, YieldPlanet, D-Edge for OTA parity and inventory control.
- CRM and guest messaging: Revinate, HiJiffy, or PMS-native tools for prearrival upsells and in-stay chat.
- Payments: PSD2-ready terminals and virtual cards for OTA payments; explain holds and charges clearly.
- Housekeeping and maintenance apps: real-time room readiness and service request tracking.
- Translation helpers: on-device translation apps for quick clarifications with non-Romanian speakers.
Human guardrails
- Never let screens replace eye contact. Start with the guest, then the keyboard.
- Give receptionists permission to override scripts for empathy and common sense.
- Use templates to standardize; use judgement to personalize.
Hiring and Developing Stellar Reception Teams in Romania
Front-office excellence starts with recruitment. Define the role beyond tasks - you are hiring brand ambassadors.
Ideal receptionist profile
- Languages: Romanian plus confident English; second language is a plus (Italian, French, Spanish, German, Hungarian in Timisoara, or Hebrew for certain inbound markets).
- Competencies: active listening, problem-solving, numerical accuracy, calm under pressure, and digital literacy.
- Attitudes: curiosity about the city, empathy, and accountability.
Salary ranges and benefits in 2025 - typical across Romanian cities
- Entry-level receptionist net monthly:
- Bucharest: 3,200 to 4,200 RON net (approx. 650 to 850 EUR)
- Cluj-Napoca: 3,000 to 4,000 RON net (approx. 600 to 800 EUR)
- Timisoara: 2,800 to 3,800 RON net (approx. 560 to 760 EUR)
- Iasi: 2,800 to 3,600 RON net (approx. 560 to 720 EUR)
- Senior receptionist or shift leader:
- 4,200 to 5,500 RON net (approx. 850 to 1,100 EUR) depending on brand and language skills
- Front Office Supervisor or Duty Manager:
- 5,500 to 7,500 RON net (approx. 1,100 to 1,500 EUR)
- Front Office Manager:
- 7,500 to 11,000 RON net (approx. 1,500 to 2,200 EUR) for upscale city hotels
Notes
- Ranges vary with brand standard, hotel category, schedule complexity, and night shift premiums.
- Many employers offer meal vouchers, transport allowances, health insurance, night shift and weekend pay differentials, and quarterly bonuses linked to review scores or upsell performance.
Typical employers and examples in the four cities
- International brands:
- Bucharest: JW Marriott Bucharest Grand Hotel, Radisson Blu Hotel Bucharest, Hilton Garden Inn Bucharest Old Town, Novotel Bucharest City Centre, Grand Hotel Bucharest.
- Cluj-Napoca: Radisson Blu Hotel, Cluj; Hampton by Hilton Cluj-Napoca; Platinia Hotel.
- Timisoara: NH Timisoara, Ibis Styles Timisoara, Hampton by Hilton Timisoara.
- Iasi: Ramada by Wyndham Iasi City Center, International Iasi Hotel, Unirea Hotel and Spa.
- Romanian hotel groups: Continental Hotels, Ana Hotels, and independent boutiques with strong local reputations.
Hiring process best practices
- Structured interviews with situational questions:
- Tell me about a time you turned around an unhappy guest.
- How would you explain a credit card hold to a first-time traveler?
- A guest insists breakfast was included on an OTA booking, but your PMS says no. What do you do?
- Role-play in both English and Romanian for check-in, complaint handling, and invoice issuance.
- Skills tests: typing speed, numerical accuracy on folio splits, and basic PMS navigation.
- Reference checks focusing on reliability and teamwork.
Retention tactics
- Publish clear career paths from receptionist to supervisor to duty manager.
- Offer city knowledge workshops and F&B tastings to keep curiosity alive.
- Recognize service recovery wins in monthly town halls.
How ELEC can help
- ELEC specializes in recruiting multilingual front-office talent and leaders across Romania and the wider region. We pre-assess language, empathy, and problem-solving so you onboard with confidence.
Training Playbook: From Onboarding to Mastery in 90 Days
High-performing reception teams do not happen by accident. Build a structured training plan with practice, feedback, and reinforcement.
30-60-90 day plan
- Days 1-30 - Foundation
- Orientation on brand values, house rules, and GDPR basics.
- PMS logins and core workflows: check-in, check-out, payments, folio adjustments, room moves.
- SALUT framework and complaint handling basics.
- Shadowing on 3 shifts: morning, evening, night.
- Days 31-60 - Autonomy with coaching
- Handle independent check-ins and check-outs.
- Cross-train with housekeeping and maintenance for room readiness coordination.
- Begin revenue tasks: upsells, early check-ins, late checkouts.
- First review of KPIs and feedback.
- Days 61-90 - Mastery and leadership behaviors
- Manage small group arrivals.
- Lead a service recovery case from start to follow-up response online.
- Train a new hire on one procedure to cement knowledge.
Microlearning topics (30 minutes each)
- Explaining deposits and holds without friction.
- OTA nuances: rate types, breakfast inclusions, and virtual cards.
- Accessibility and inclusive language.
- Handling frustration and de-escalation.
- Cross-selling F&B and spa.
City immersion modules
- Bucharest: business districts, Old Town footfall patterns, and public transport connections.
- Cluj-Napoca: event calendar, coffee and dining map, and co-working spaces.
- Timisoara: industrial areas, cultural sites, and stadium schedule.
- Iasi: hospitals and clinics, university campuses, and heritage sites.
Assessment and certification
- Weekly 10-question quizzes.
- Two observed role-plays per month.
- Sign-off checklist for independent duty.
SOPs and Checklists You Can Use Today
Clear SOPs free your team to focus on the guest.
Pre-shift huddle - 10-point checklist
- VIP and special occasions list for the day.
- Early arrivals and late departures flagged in the PMS.
- Maintenance and out-of-order rooms update.
- Group arrivals and bus schedules.
- Housekeeping readiness forecast.
- Parking and transfer bookings.
- Weather and flight alerts for OTP, CLJ, TSR, IAS.
- F&B specials and hours.
- Upsell offers and price points.
- Review of any online reviews needing personalized responses.
30-second check-in script
- Greeting: Good afternoon, welcome back Ms. Popescu.
- Confirmation: We have you for 2 nights, king room with breakfast, correct?
- Key info: Breakfast 7-10 a.m. on Level 1. Wi-Fi code is on the key card. Gym 24 hours with your key.
- Payment: A temporary hold of 300 RON will be placed for incidentals.
- Close: Here are your keys. The lifts are to your right. Please tell us anything you need.
5-step complaint handling SOP
- Listen fully without interrupting.
- Apologize for the impact, not just the issue.
- Offer two realistic options and confirm the choice.
- Take action immediately and set a time to update.
- Follow up and log the case with outcome and guest sentiment.
Night audit essentials
- Balance folios, verify rates, and release unused holds per policy.
- Pre-assign rooms for early arrivals and VIPs with notes.
- Run daily reports for management: occupancy, ADR, RevPAR, and complaints.
Review Management and Social Proof: Turn Guests Into Advocates
Proactive review strategy is reputation insurance. Reception is the catalyst.
Before checkout
- Ask about the stay: On a scale of 1 to 10, how was your stay? Anything we can improve before you go?
- Rescue on the spot if the score is under 8.
At checkout
- Invite feedback: We are glad you stayed with us. If you have a moment to share your experience on Google or Booking.com, it helps other travelers.
- Provide a QR code card linking to your preferred platform. Avoid incentives that violate OTA rules.
After checkout
- Send a short thank-you with a direct booking perk for next time if your brand policy allows.
Response templates
- Positive review: Thank you for your kind words about our team and location. We are delighted you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you again in Bucharest soon.
- Negative review with validity: Thank you for the feedback about noise. We are sorry for the disturbance and have upgraded window seals on the 3rd floor. Please contact us directly so we can ensure a quiet room for your next stay.
- Negative review with mismatch: Thank you for sharing your perspective. Our records show the reservation was for room only; however, we appreciate the confusion and have clarified our listing to avoid future misunderstandings.
Staff guidelines
- Never debate a guest online. Express empathy, take accountability, and move the conversation offline for resolution.
- Mention concrete corrective actions to show progress.
Accessibility, Safety, and Compliance in Romania
Excellence includes doing the right thing consistently.
Accessibility
- Keep at least one accessible front desk point or alternative seating.
- Maintain an updated list of accessible rooms and equipment such as shower chairs.
- Use person-first language and ask before assisting.
Safety and emergencies
- All receptionists should know evacuation routes, assembly points, and fire panel basics.
- Keep an incident log. Document time, people involved, actions taken, and follow-up.
Data privacy and guest registration
- Collect only data needed to provide service and comply with national guest registration requirements.
- Obtain consent for marketing communications and respect opt-outs.
- Securely store and delete scanned IDs per policy and legal requirements.
Payments and billing
- Explain holds and refunds clearly.
- Train on PSD2 and 3-D Secure flows for online prepayments.
Calculating the ROI of Better Service
Use straightforward math to justify investment in people and training.
Example: Bucharest 120-room hotel, 80 percent annual occupancy
- Rooms sold per year: 120 x 0.80 x 365 = 35,040
- Upsell opportunity: If reception sells a 10 EUR per night upgrade to 8 percent of arrivals, annual upsell revenue is 35,040 x 0.08 x 10 = 28,032 EUR.
- Review score lift: Moving Booking.com from 8.8 to 9.1 increases conversion and may allow a 3 EUR ADR premium at similar occupancy. ADR premium impact: 35,040 room nights x 3 EUR = 105,120 EUR.
- Complaint reduction: Cutting compensation vouchers by 1,000 RON per month saves 12,000 RON annually.
Training investment
- Suppose you invest 400 EUR per receptionist per year in training. For a 12-person team, that is 4,800 EUR. The combined upside above easily exceeds this by a factor of 20 or more.
The Path Forward: Elevate Your Reception, Elevate Your Brand
Stellar customer service is not a layer you add on top of your operation. It is the operation. Reception is where brand promises become facts for guests who will, in turn, shape your reputation online and offline. In Romania's competitive hotel markets - from corporate Bucharest to creative Cluj-Napoca, industrious Timisoara, and welcoming Iasi - the hotels that win are the ones that transform check-in into a relationship.
Action steps you can take this month
- Adopt the SALUT framework and role-play two scenarios per week.
- Publish a 10-point pre-shift huddle and measure check-in times.
- Link a small team bonus to review response times and upsell revenue per occupied room.
- Map city-specific guest expectations with your team and update local recommendations.
- Audit your review responses for empathy, specificity, and corrective actions.
Partner with ELEC
- If you need multilingual receptionists, shift leaders, or front office managers who can deliver the above from day one, ELEC can help. We recruit, pre-assess, and place hospitality talent across Romania and the wider region, and we design training programs that turn good teams into great ones. Contact our team to discuss your hiring plan for Bucharest, Cluj-Napoca, Timisoara, or Iasi.
Frequently Asked Questions
1) What front-office skills are non-negotiable for hotels in Romania?
- Clear communication in Romanian and English, numerical accuracy for billing, empathy under stress, and confidence with PMS workflows. A second foreign language, strong local knowledge, and quick typing speed are valuable differentiators.
2) How can we reduce check-in times without feeling rushed?
- Pre-assign rooms and pre-verify payments, print or digitalize registration forms, and teach a crisp 30-second script. Focus on eye contact first, keystrokes second. Offer luggage tags and a lounge seat for early arrivals to relieve pressure on the queue.
3) What salary should we offer a receptionist in Bucharest or Cluj-Napoca?
- As a guide, 3,200 to 4,200 RON net per month in Bucharest and 3,000 to 4,000 RON net in Cluj-Napoca, with benefits and night or weekend premiums. Strong language skills, upscale brand standards, and night audit duties push the range higher.
4) How much does a small improvement in reviews matter commercially?
- A move from 8.8 to 9.1 on Booking.com or a consistent 4.6 on Google can significantly increase visibility and conversion. Many hotels see a 2 to 4 EUR ADR lift and higher direct bookings when reviews highlight service reliability and problem-solving.
5) What are the top reasons guests complain at reception, and how do we prevent them?
- Most complaints cluster around noise, billing confusion, maintenance delays, and mismatched expectations from OTAs. Prevention tactics include clear prearrival messaging, transparent deposit explanations, fast room moves, and loud-room contingency plans.
6) Which technologies deliver the biggest gains for front-office performance?
- A cloud PMS with stable integrations, a reliable channel manager, a guest messaging tool for prearrival upsells and in-stay support, and housekeeping or maintenance apps for real-time room readiness. Add translation tools for quick clarifications with non-Romanian speakers.
7) How does ELEC support hotels beyond recruitment?
- In addition to recruiting frontline and leadership talent, ELEC designs onboarding and service training, implements SOPs, and helps define KPIs and dashboards so reception teams hit performance targets faster and sustain them over time.